← All answers

Do I need an app?

Maybe not yet. If customers aren't showing up steadily, fix that first, because an app with nobody using it earns nothing. Once customers are coming in, an app can make sense.

By Carey McLean, software engineer for 26+ years

The short answer

Maybe not yet. If customers aren't showing up steadily, that's the first thing to fix. Once they are, you can talk about the build.

We build apps for a living, so this might sound odd. We'd still rather tell you "not yet" than build something that sits empty.

Why an app is rarely the first fix

An app is a place for customers to go. It doesn't send customers there.

Say you run a small design studio and you're losing sleep over missed bookings. You might think a booking app is the answer. But if only three new people a month ask about your work, the app has three people to serve. A great app and three visitors is still three visitors.

Fix the flow of new customers first. Then ask what would make your existing customers' lives easier. That second question is the one an app answers well.

Signs you don't need one yet

  • New customers arrive in bursts. A good month, then quiet. Nothing steady to plan around.
  • People ask, then go silent. The problem is follow-up, and software won't fix it.
  • You can't say who your best customer is. An app built for "everyone" is built for nobody.
  • Your week is full of one repeated chore. Name the chore first. It may not need software at all.

If two of these sound like you, an app can wait.

Signs you might

An app starts to earn its keep when most of these are true:

  • Customers come in steadily. You're busy, and the busy part is getting messy.
  • The same task eats hours every week. Booking, quoting, reminders, hand-offs.
  • Customers keep asking for it. They want to do something themselves, without calling you.
  • One customer is worth real money. The build cost makes sense against what each customer brings in.

None of these means "build it today." They mean the conversation is worth having.

What we'd do on a call

We'd ask where your customers come from, how many call you in a month, and what slips through the cracks. It takes a short online call, not a pitch.

You'd leave knowing the one thing to fix first. Sometimes that's an app. More often it's the flow of new customers, and that's what our Growth Engine is for.

When the answer is no

We're not the right people if you want an app mostly because a competitor has one. A competitor's app tells you nothing about your customers.

We'd also tell you to stay put if the idea is untested. Talk to ten customers before you spend a dollar on software.

The longer version

Owners often tell us they need an app because everyone around them seems to have one, and because a competitor launched something that looked impressive on a phone, but nobody in that story ever mentions whether the app brought in a single new customer or just gave existing customers a nicer way to do what they already did. Ask that question first. It's cheap. It saves a lot.

Here's a simple test you can run this week without spending anything: write down how many new customers found you in the last ninety days, where each one came from, and how many of them would have used an app if you'd had one, and if the last number is close to zero then the app isn't your next move, however good the idea feels. Numbers settle arguments.

Keep reading

Book my call

A short online call. We'll talk about your business, find the one thing to fix first, and say plainly whether the Growth Engine is a fit. No pressure either way.

Book my call